nytimes.com/For Chinese, Pope Seems Worlds Away in South Korea


SHAFAQNA-  Pu Ge sat on a green bench outside Beijing’s oldest Catholic cathedral and stared at the ornate gray edifice, contemplating God and his shepherd. She said she had thought that Pope Francis would stop in China during his current trip to Asia. “I thought he would visit a church here and we would get a chance to meet him,” said Ms. Pu, 27, a dance teacher. “I would like to meet him, but it seems so distant.” Given the long history of tensions between the Vatican and the Chinese Communist Party, the Chinese state media have been less than forthcoming with reports about the pope and the Catholic establishment. Broad coverage of the pope’s first visit to East Asia, which began Thursday in South Korea, was absent here.

The sparse news treatment is indicative of the party’s continuing attempts to maintain a tight grip on Catholicism, as the number of Chinese followers grows each year, and as those followers try by various means to learn more about Pope Francis. The Vatican has just as great an interest in them, and also in trying to improve relations with the Communist Party. There have been signs of some warming, even if the establishment of formal ties remains years or decades off, if the party permits it at all.

While addressing bishops south of Seoul on Sunday, the pope referred cordially to China and other Asian nations with which the Vatican does not have formal relations, in his strongest outreach yet to those governments. “In this spirit of openness to others, I earnestly hope that those countries of your continent with whom the Holy See does not yet enjoy a full relationship may not hesitate to further a dialogue for the benefit of all,” he said.

He then deviated from a prepared text, according to The Associated Press. “I’m not talking here only about a political dialogue, but about a fraternal dialogue,” the pope said, assuring that “Christians aren’t coming as conquerors” to strip away any nation’s “identity.” The important thing, he said, was to “walk together.”

Breaking with tradition on Thursday, the Chinese government allowed the pope’s jet to fly through Chinese airspace as he traveled to Seoul. While above China, the pope broadcast via radio telegram a message to Xi Jinping, the Chinese president and party leader, offering his best wishes and blessings of peace.

Li Zhigang, a volunteer at the Xuanwumen Cathedral in southern Beijing, where Ms. Pu was sitting outdoors on Friday afternoon, said: “Of course, we’d like his blessings to be realized. Chinese Catholics are devoted followers of the pope.”

Mr. Li, 55, was among a dozen people praying that afternoon inside the church, known formally as the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception. It was established in 1605, when the Italian Jesuit missionary Matteo Ricci set up residence near here.

The priests and nuns of Xuanwumen are on one side of a sharp divide in Chinese Catholicism, which is one of five religions recognized by the party. This cathedral is officially approved by the Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association, a state organization that, to the chagrin of the Vatican, controls the practice of Catholicism in China, including the appointment of bishops.

Continue reading the main story Slide Show

Pope Francis in South Korea

CreditAgence France-Presse — Getty Images

On the other side of the divide are the so-called underground churches, which exist nationwide and are tolerated by local officials. At those churches, discussion of the pope and his authority is more open than at the official cathedrals. About half of China’s approximately 15 million Catholics worship at underground churches, said Lionel Jensen, an associate professor at the University of Notre Dame who specializes in religion in China.

“In the end,” Mr. Jensen said, “the numbers cannot tell us what is seen on the ground, that Catholic services are increasingly well attended, even packed, and that the Vatican is aware that the popularity of Catholicism is growing.”

That is the case at an underground church outside the city of Shijiazhuang in Hebei Province, where the Rev. Dong Baolu leads a parish of about 2,000. Despite the growing number of Catholics in China, Father Dong said he did not anticipate a visit here by the pope anytime soon.

“There is no way to establish formal diplomacy now,” he said in a telephone interview. “That is because a real Communist Party won’t tolerate independent religion. Even if you’re allowed to follow your faith, that’s within its control. There is no way that it will allow you to follow foreign leadership.”

He said it was a “good thing” that Pope Francis had been allowed to fly over China, but also questioned the terms of whatever agreement had been reached between the Vatican and the Chinese government to permit it.

“I think the deal itself is bad for those churches that are loyal and true and underground, because the Communist Party’s policy hasn’t changed,” Father Dong said. “Religion is still under the leadership of the Communist Party.”

Pope and South Korean President on Peace

Pope Francis, in his visit to Seoul, called for efforts toward reconciliation between North and South Korea. Meanwhile, President Park Geun-hye urged North Korea to give up its nuclear ambition.

Publish Date August 14, 2014. Image CreditPool photo by Kim Hong-Ji
Even at the official Xuanwumen Cathedral, people understood the realities.

“Of course, South Korea is more developed as a Catholic country than China,” said Chen Kuo, 29, a clothing salesman. “But the fact that the pope chose to go to Korea rather than China makes me feel disappointed in the Chinese government’s policies toward Catholicism and Catholics.”

Some young Chinese Catholics made it to South Korea to see the pope, while others trying to go there were stopped by local officials, said Ren Dahai, who heads a Catholic charity in Hebei Province.

One young woman outside Xuanwumen Cathedral said the priest who leads her worship group in Hebei Province had announced that some people from the congregation were traveling to South Korea.

“Someone in my group said he had seen the pope in Rome,” said the woman, Hu Kangya, 18, on summer break before entering university. “I was so envious.”

Mr. Jensen, the American scholar, said that the pope’s passage above China was “a small but singular event,” and that his message to both Mr. Xi and the Chinese people “was another promising gesture of communication between the Vatican and Beijing, even more so as the Foreign Ministry made a statement of their interest in constructive dialogue.”

Mr. Jensen continued: “The general trend in Vatican and Chinese Communist Party relations has been toward decreasing friction, and thus overall improvement. However, this is only from comparison with the more violent vitriol and threats that characterized Beijing’s past relations with the Holy See.”

Mr. Jensen said he thought that “there are some in the party who do believe that China’s status as a modern nation with global presence and responsibilities must come to terms with the widespread growth of Christianity in China, and this means a reasonable accommodation with the Vatican.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here